THREE GENERATIONS OF EXTERIOR EXCELLENCEFamily owned in Western PA
Call 724-816-0290Request an estimate

A HOMEOWNER’S GUIDE • WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA

Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

The best roof isn’t always the most expensive. It’s the system that makes sense for your home, your budget, and your long-term plans.

Pennsylvania roofs face rain, snow, ice, wind, summer heat, and repeated freeze–thaw cycles. At Bricker Exteriors, we explain the differences between materials so you can invest confidently, not just choose the lowest price.

Three roofing systems we recommend

We install these options based on the home’s design, roof slope, ventilation needs, and your goals—not a one-size-fits-all sales pitch.

MOST POPULAR • BEST OVERALL VALUE

Architectural Asphalt Shingles

A dependable choice for most homes, combining attractive dimensional style with a reasonable installed cost. We often recommend Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles.

  • Great balance of value and curb appeal
  • Many colors and styles
  • Product-specific wind and warranty options
  • A practical choice for most residential roofs

Our take: A quality architectural shingle is the smart starting point for most homeowners.

PREMIUM • TRADITIONAL LOOK

Tilcor Stone-Coated Steel

For homeowners who prefer the familiar look of shingles but want a premium steel roof. Tilcor’s CF Shingle system uses a concealed-fastener design.

  • Stone-coated steel construction
  • Traditional shingle-style profile
  • Concealed fastening on CF Shingle systems
  • An excellent premium upgrade where suitable

Our take: Consider Tilcor when you want a classic appearance with premium metal construction.

PREMIUM • MODERN LOOK

Standing Seam Metal

A sleek premium metal roofing option with raised seams and concealed attachment methods. It delivers a modern appearance while reducing the number of exposed fastener points.

  • Clean, architectural lines
  • Concealed fasteners
  • Long-term performance when properly detailed
  • Distinctive curb appeal

Our take: A strong choice for homeowners who like a modern appearance and want a premium metal roof.

Every material has installation requirements, limitations, and warranty conditions. We’ll explain what applies to your specific roof.

Roofing products we generally steer homeowners away from

Some inexpensive roofing products have a place, but we believe the right application matters more than the lowest upfront price.

Exposed-Fastener Metal Roofing

Available for unheated outbuildings—not offered for homes or heated structures.

Exposed-fastener panels rely on screws and sealing washers that remain exposed to weather. Those washers and attachment points can need monitoring and replacement over time, and poor maintenance can increase leak risk.

We will install exposed-fastener metal on qualifying barns, sheds, agricultural buildings, and other unheated outbuildings. However, Bricker Exteriors does not offer or install exposed-fastener metal roofing on residential homes or heated structures.

For homes and heated buildings, we recommend considering standing seam or a suitable concealed-fastener roofing system.

Traditional 3-Tab Shingles

Three-tab asphalt shingles have historically been a budget option. For most full residential roof replacements today, we recommend architectural shingles instead because they offer a more dimensional look and often stronger product and warranty choices.

Our take: We generally steer homeowners away from 3-tab shingles when a quality architectural shingle is a better long-term value.

The whole roofing system matters

Even a premium roofing product can underperform if the supporting system is overlooked. We evaluate:

  • Attic intake and exhaust ventilation
  • Ice-and-water protection and underlayment
  • Flashing, penetrations, and water-shedding details
  • Roof slope, drainage, and decking condition
  • Manufacturer-approved installation requirements

We recommend materials and installation details based on your specific home. Our goal is a roofing system built to perform—not simply new material on an old problem.

Not sure which roof is right for you?

We’ll inspect your roof, explain the options, and help you weigh value, appearance, and long-term performance. No pressure—just straightforward answers.

Prefer to talk? Call or text 724-816-0290.

Bricker Exteriors • Three Generations of Exterior Excellence